Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Aguilera Vs Gaga
Delta Goodrem's Official Forum > Other Discussions > Music Discussions
Pages: 1, 2
Martin
Well recently the dumbass, Perez Hilton, had sparked heaps of crap between the two singers by claiming that Christina was in fact copying Lady Gaga's style.

This has brought a rift between Gaga, who is not frankly worried, and Christina, who is unhappy with these claims.

After Christina's Video Music Award performance she was wildly compared to Lady Gaga, where her new track was also targetted as a "wanna be Lady Gaga hit".
Now a picture from Christina's new album photoshoot has surfaced and Perez thinks it looks remarkably like a screencap from Gaga's video clip for Just Dance.

When Lady Gaga was asked what she thought she said:
QUOTE
"A lot of people have been saying that she is copying my style with her new song. I guess it bares somewhat of a resemblance but I wouldn't say she is copying me. This type of dance music is becoming more popular and I don't blame her for wanting to make and perform it. Her performance was great and it's (Keeps Gettin Better) a hot track."


Though the lovely Christina goes out of her way to badmouth Lady Gaga:
QUOTE
What did you say to those on the Internet who are hinting that you borrowed Lady Gaga’s look?

You know, that’s funny that you mention that. This person [Lady Gaga] was just brought to my attention not too long ago. I’m not quite sure who this person is, to be honest. I don’t know if it is a man or a woman. I just wasn’t sure. I really don’t spend any time on the Internet, so I guess I live a little under a rock in that respect.



So whos side are you on? I think it's obvious I'm on Christinas side, even if she is insulting Lady Gaga, it's not like Lady Gaga is gonna be around as long as Christina anyway!
Artin
Christina had to be a *insert word* and badmouth Gaga. When she obviously stole her look.

I am on Gaga's side.

I like both their music smile.gif

Artin
Martin
QUOTE(Artin @ Nov 15 2008, 02:38 PM) *

Christina had to be a *insert word* and badmouth Gaga. When she obviously stole her look.

I am on Gaga's side.

I like both their music smile.gif

Artin

Somedays I'm a super bitch up to my own tricks but it won't last forever. whistling.gif
Artin
QUOTE(Martin @ Nov 15 2008, 02:40 PM) *

Somedays I'm a super bitch up to my own tricks and it will last forever. whistling.gif

whistling.gif

Artin
Martin
QUOTE(Artin @ Nov 15 2008, 02:43 PM) *

whistling.gif i hate britney she's such a dog

Artin

Now that's just super bitchy! laugh.gif and true wink2.gif
Jon
Team Gaga! Rah-rah-rah! tease.gif
Artin
QUOTE(Martin @ Nov 15 2008, 02:44 PM) *

Now that's just super bitchy! laugh.gif and true wink2.gif

How dare you edit my post! ohmy.gif

Artin
delbrit
Gaga,


you don't steal somebody elses idea then bash them (it came out in -ing July this year, before Keeps Getting Better was even a thought in her brain), that's just low, then go and say you took inspiration from other brands (the Dandy Worhol resemblance I don't see), and not give credit where its due, and never ever call a fellow person This Person, that's just disrespectful...Super - doesn't even cover it!...and the whole Man Or Woman thing I don't get, that just makes Xtina sound like an idiot!
Martin
QUOTE(delbrit @ Nov 15 2008, 02:51 PM) *

Gaga,
you don't steal somebody elses idea then bash them (it came out in -ing July this year, before Keeps Getting Better was even a thought in her brain), that's just low, then go and say you took inspiration from other brands (the Dandy Worhol resemblance I don't see), and not give credit where its due, and never ever call a fellow person This Person, that's just disrespectful...Super - doesn't even cover it!...and the whole Man Or Woman thing I don't get, that just makes Xtina sound like an idiot!

She got inspiration from ANDY WORHOL, get it right!

And honest to god, tell me Lady Gaga isn't just a huge rip off of Gwen Stefani. Just say that and I'll dig up every single bloody picture of both of them, and I'll show you how much Gaga's songs rip off Gwen.
Katiekins
GaGa.

Christina may not be stealing Lady GaGa's look but her stylist certainly is. And yeah, during the VMA performance when she started with the Genie 2.0 part, I kept looking at and I swore it was Lady GaGa.

Oh and the photo that Perez things is from the Just Dance video? Is it the one in the sweater and she's pulling it over her face? I thought it was so similar to the video as well.
Martin
QUOTE(Katiekins @ Nov 15 2008, 02:56 PM) *

GaGa.

Christina may not be stealing Lady GaGa's look but her stylist certainly is. And yeah, during the VMA performance when she started with the Genie 2.0 part, I kept looking at and I swore it was Lady GaGa.

Oh and the photo that Perez things is from the Just Dance video? Is it the one in the sweater and she's pulling it over her face? I thought it was so similar to the video as well.

Yeah it is... but still I'm sure heaps of people have done that, does that mean that Lady Gaga is ripping off anyone else whos done that?
Katiekins
QUOTE(Martin @ Nov 14 2008, 09:58 PM) *

Yeah it is... but still I'm sure heaps of people have done that, does that mean that Lady Gaga is ripping off anyone else whos done that?


No but the thing is, it's so recent with Lady GaGa doing it and then Christina does it - of course people are ging to compare them and maybe say that Christina is ripping her off. Is she? Not necessarily, no. Could the photographer? Possibly. That's the thing people don't get it. The look? Her stylist, most likely. The clothes? Again, stylist. The photoshoot? Photographer and stylist. The sound? Producers, writers, mixers, etc.

The reason why I picked GaGa instead of Christina is the way Christina handled the situation. It makes her look childish.
Martin
QUOTE(Katiekins @ Nov 15 2008, 03:01 PM) *

No but the thing is, it's so recent with Lady GaGa doing it and then Christina does it - of course people are ging to compare them and maybe say that Christina is ripping her off. Is she? Not necessarily, no. Could the photographer? Possibly. That's the thing people don't get it. The look? Her stylist, most likely. The clothes? Again, stylist. The photoshoot? Photographer and stylist. The sound? Producers, writers, mixers, etc.

The reason why I picked GaGa instead of Christina is the way Christina handled the situation. It makes her look childish.

Lol but Christina is always seen "COPYING" someone. Even with Back To Basics she was copying people from the 50s, no shit she was that was the point of the album!

I guess when you're Christina and people keep saying you're stealing looks then you'd obviously be fed up.
listentome
Gaga is ripping of Gwen Stefani's music, vocals and look smile.gif
markndelta
lady gaga ftw.

cristina is a lying b!tch.

who doesn't know if someone is male or female when their stage name is LADY gaga.

fkn liar. she woulda been googling and youtubing her for days, weeks, months before her comeback.
Katiekins
QUOTE(Martin @ Nov 14 2008, 10:05 PM) *

Lol but Christina is always seen "COPYING" someone. Even with Back To Basics she was copying people from the 50s, no shit she was that was the point of the album!

I guess when you're Christina and people keep saying you're stealing looks then you'd obviously be fed up.


You obviously didn't read into what I said and assumed I was "attacking" Christina.
Martin
QUOTE(Katiekins @ Nov 15 2008, 03:07 PM) *

You obviously didn't read into what I said and assumed I was "attacking" Christina.

Lol, I know you weren't attacking her. I was simply saying that when you're constantly compared to other people you would get sick of it very easily.

First is was Britney, then it was everyone in the 50s, now Lady Gaga. It happens every album.
Katiekins
QUOTE(Martin @ Nov 14 2008, 10:12 PM) *

Lol, I know you weren't attacking her. I was simply saying that when you're constantly compared to other people you would get sick of it very easily.

First is was Britney, then it was everyone in the 50s, now Lady Gaga. It happens every album.


But that's how the industry is. Britney was always compared to Madonna and she was even compared to Christina as well. People will always be compared to someone from the past or from five days ago, it doesn't matter. I doubt she lets it bother her but saying something like "I don't even know if that's a man or a woman" is childish and makes her sound ignorant.

It wasn't just everyone in the 50's, either. It was mainly Marilyn Monroe. Scarlett Johansson got compared to her as well.
Andrew_1992
Christina !
Martin
QUOTE(Katiekins @ Nov 15 2008, 03:15 PM) *

But that's how the industry is. Britney was always compared to Madonna and she was even compared to Christina as well. People will always be compared to someone from the past or from five days ago, it doesn't matter. I doubt she lets it bother her but saying something like "I don't even know if that's a man or a woman" is childish and makes her sound ignorant.

It wasn't just everyone in the 50's, either. It was mainly Marilyn Monroe. Scarlett Johansson got compared to her as well.

Yeah, I do know that's how the industry is but ever since like Britney's greatest hits she's been established and now she just can't be compared. Christina has got her greatest hits out, but she's being compared to some new girl which I promise you will not be around 5 years from now. At least compare her to someone like Gwen Stefani who has been here for almost two decades and has clearly inspired "Lady Gaga".
Mad_about_Delta
GaGa.

Christina looks fug these days. The greatest hits album cover makes me shudder.

I love both their music though.
lwoutyou
Lady GaGa all the mo-effin' way! I think Christina Aguilera is a vile human being.
Bianca Claire
team gaga ftw.
Luke
TEAM GAGA FTW! WOOOP
charmedchick
Neither tbh, but Christina is 59575x better than Lady GaGa. I was so disappointed with her album, there's only 2 half decent songs on there =|
Martin
QUOTE(charmedchick @ Nov 16 2008, 12:59 AM) *

Neither tbh, but Christina is 59575x better than Lady GaGa. I was so disappointed with her album, there's only 2 half decent songs on there =|

Lol, I hope you mean Lady Gaga's album laugh.gif
Unwritten
sigh. this is just another phase for Xtina. She'll most likely change her looks again for the 4th studio album.
Andrei.
GaGa , time for new people in the industry. Xtina is so yestarday
Stop the Train
I'm the one person who voted neither. I really liked Christina through her early days {Dirrty etc} but since her last album I went majorly off her. She's become too much of a diva and always acts stuck up in her interviews, plus not to mention concert ticket prices that are just ridiculous for her second ever tour. I like how she takes a different direction each album though.
On the other hand I first heard about Lady GaGa on this forum a few weeks ago and youtubed her yesterday, and what's the fuss with her? One song was semi ok. The others sounded bad.
It's getting them both publicity though...

QUOTE(Unwritten @ Nov 15 2008, 04:21 PM) *

sigh. this is just another phase for Xtina. She'll most likely change her looks again for the 4th studio album.

That's a good thing.

QUOTE(Andrei. @ Nov 15 2008, 04:47 PM) *

GaGa , time for new people in the industry. Xtina is so yestarday

Says you with the Britney sig. whistling.gif I actually like Britney but you can't say Christina should leave the industry when her original rival is someone you support! tongue.gif
Anna_was_born2try
exclaim.gif oh please.....Christina is way better.

angry.gif though I'm not a fan, I admit she has one of the best voices in the world. biggrin.gif
Katiekins
QUOTE(Stop the Train @ Nov 15 2008, 02:12 PM) *

Says you with the Britney sig. whistling.gif I actually like Britney but you can't say Christina should leave the industry when her original rival is someone you support! tongue.gif


There we go with the Britney vs. Christina stuff again. rolleyes.gif
Stop the Train
QUOTE(Katiekins @ Nov 15 2008, 08:47 PM) *

There we go with the Britney vs. Christina stuff again. rolleyes.gif

I was merely using Britney as an example. Someone saying we should have new acts in the music industry - saying that Christina should go, but at the same time someone who came on the scene at the same time ie. Britney should stay? The person I was replying to had a Britney sig, that's why I made an example of Britney. I would have said the same if it was Justin Timberlake, GA, anyone who has been around for a few years. rolleyes.gif
Katiekins
QUOTE(Stop the Train @ Nov 15 2008, 03:43 PM) *

I was merely using Britney as an example. Someone saying we should have new acts in the music industry - saying that Christina should go, but at the same time someone who came on the scene at the same time ie. Britney should stay? The person I was replying to had a Britney sig, that's why I made an example of Britney. I would have said the same if it was Justin Timberlake, GA, anyone who has been around for a few years. rolleyes.gif


I don't agree with that Christina should go but she shouldn't have done a Greatest Hits album, too soon, honestly. She's been around as long as Britney but hasn't released as many albums as Britney, for example.

But I do agree that we need new people in the industry that aren't rap or hip hop artists and Lady GaGa isn't either of those things.
Natasha Harrison
Lady GaGa! w00t.gif Just Dance is like <3. I really don't care much for Christina, not that I have anything bad to say about her.
x_LastNightOnEarth_x
They both suck w00t.gif
Avrilz
I love them both but I'm on Lady GaGa's side.
What Christina said was a really b!tchy thing to say and stupid.
Carbon_77
Although I love both, I think Christina just Keeps Gettin' Better with every song!
heidi loves delta
i love christina's music but i'm on gaga's side. happy.gif
xx
Andrei.
Well Christina is always bitchy and rude and she should shut the fck up somethimes. She's so annoying and the only thing she knows to do is to copy other people. Just an other cheap copy.
:.miss_innocent_eyes.:
I dislike both of them
Sophii3x
I love them both, but I've got to say I'm on GaGa's side. You don't take someones else's look and then diss them.. and the man/woman comment was uncalled for.
Joshua
What Mark said about the stage name.
Yeah, I'm on team Gaga, sorry Martin tongue.gif
kirkitus
I think Christina must be living under not just a rock, but like the earth's crust to not know Lady Gaga and "Just Dance" laugh.gif GAGA ALL THE WAY!!!!
lil_mayvis
Lady Gaga is funky as!!!
No.1 Fan
LADY GAGA BY FAR

SHES HEAPS BETTER (L)

lost_for_words89
i love Lady Gaga's style is so fresh & new, its awesome! i love her album, its awesome, i can see it wearing thin quickly..

i love Christina too much to choose over lady gaga.
Martin
QUOTE(lost_for_words89 @ Nov 26 2008, 05:44 PM) *

i love Lady Gaga's style is so fresh & new, its awesome! i love her album, its awesome, i can see it wearing thin quickly..

i love Christina too much to choose over lady gaga.

-points to sig-

IS THAT LADY GAGA whistling.gif
lost_for_words89
QUOTE(Martin @ Nov 26 2008, 04:19 PM) *

-points to sig-

IS THAT LADY GAGA whistling.gif

who is this lady gaga..is she a man or a woman?
JimJim
GaGa is on fire atm, so she's definitely got more going for her, especially in Australia.

It's understandable that she wouldn't know GaGa though, 'Just Dance' has only just gone top 20 in the US, after lingering since like June.
loveyadelta
At least Christina can sing.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.