OMG It's - DUFF. OMGZ
The video is hot, just the direction+lighting was a bit rubbish imo.

http://vids.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseacti...ideoID=45390796

wow that was truly terrible

and 'best of' already?

wow.
her little kiddie fans are so going to like this....
im not sure what i think of the song, but the clip is really saucy.

ok that clip was horrible

I love the clip tbh...it matches the song perfectly!

tbh that clip is so good , i love it

ive liked hilary duff for ages now... but um.. im not too sure about the song and the clip!

i prefer "with love" or "stranger" that type of music!

i'll have to listen to it again and watch the clip to make up my mind!

xx

The clip was boring, it just kept going back to the same thing again and again. Song is ok.

She only released it so she can finish her contract with Hollywood Records and get more freedom elsewhere.

Artin

argh I hate this vid! it doesnt suit her! shes gone all skanky now

to be honest. i dont like skanky duff. I love sweet duff better.

Her licking the guys finger was very tempting...and does not suit her. But video wise it was hot and i like it...

While Hilary does look really beautiful in the video.. I don't really like the song or the video



same here..I definitely like the young cute "Lizzie McGuire" Hilary better
Hilary is surely growing up fast (she's already 21!) and is not afraid to show the new "wilder" side to her.
She definitely wasn't holding anything back in her role as Yonica Babyyeah in "War Inc."

*Copy and Paste*

I don't like: the puff up doll boy she is trying to be sexy with, I hate those boys, like its just, kills the song for me, I think the should've shared SOMETHING during the video, he's just like standing there, she, looking as sexy as she is, is coming onto him really really hard, and he just stands there, like a freaking puff up doll statue...
also the statue was stupid too, they could've avoided that too, she looked to stupid...oh and I also hated the finger incident, really really was like UGH!

but when she's on her own, almost anywhere, she looks sexy, she plays into that sexy-but-sweet thing really well, I think she did it really well, when she was on her own, I really really liked it..my favourite was the mirror, cuz that reminded me of Slave 4 U's video by Britney, and the general concept reminded me of My Prerogative's video by Britney...my favourite was the when she was in the water with her dress on, that was a really really good bit!....she looked most confident and inviting there!

on to the rest of the world:
I think maybe a couple of people will be like "OH Another One Gone Bad"
and she may disapoint alot of parents and young fans like people before her have done in the past, she will inevitably loose her innocence and abit of her dignity due to this video, which is NOT what she needs, this may driver her into HBville!

I find the song itself incredibly catchy as well!!

I used to ADORE her. But then I saw her change into this person I didnt like..
her videos became suddenly very s.exual and suggestive and it really shocked me. The way she is now upsets me. But I dont even really care a big deal anymore because she was my past idol. Delta is my life and I think Delta is a much better role model who acts her age and doesnt go around making skanky vids and liking guys fingers on videos. One of the reasons why I admire Delta

i absolutly love this song! The video is still ver good also. Love you hils!

im just happy shes not a LILO Pt. 2. At least not yet, and hopefully she'll never be that trainwreck.

she's 21 for god's sake . she needs to grow up

Exactly.

Shes 21, for freaks sake, Delts is 23, they both have a right to be sexy, have had for over 2 years, since they were 18, I think thats the general consensus, but good for you, but Delta has nothing to do with this music video

actually, it kinda gets me mad (off topic but has to be said)...the older you are when you start getting sexy, the more crap you get for it, like Britney/Xtina/Hilary/Lindsay Lohan et cetera who started to get sexy after the age of 18 got metaphorically murdered by the adult set for this kind of thing, but Miley can spend most of her freedom making similar types of pictures and she gets out of jail free and the media doesn't give a damn, and she's supposed to be innocent cuz she's 4 years younger then the ones who do, within reason sexie it up

What's about it? She's releasing the best of album as a quick way out off her contract with Hollywood Records.

Wow I for one really like it, I just hate the lighting. and ngl I thought she was really sexy in the vid and I loved it. I mean shes not like shes stripping or anything, I thought it was tasteful. I like that its also obviously aimed towards a higher age group, instead of all the tweeny boppers.

How has she changed Becky? shes just GROWN UP and matured. Shes an adult now no longer a teenager, it was bound to happen, plus shes a GREAT ROLE MODEL. Sure she parties but you don't see her in the tabloids like Lindsay, Paris etc. Shes a far more REALISTIC one too imo.

words of wisdom!

Agree with this...and I agree with the bolded part in the last post.

I used to adore her when I was like, 9 and to me, she was the greatest singer in the world and the best actress and then I turned 10, and then one day she turned into the biggest skank. Yes, she grew up, but when everyone grows up, do they turn into skanks? Last I checked, they didn't...

It's good to see that the one thing that hasn't changed is that she still can't sing!

umm.. if anything Hilary has become a better singer. Dignity is by far my favourite album of hers.

btw, one thing I've noticed which is starting to get real old in Hilary's more recent videos is the inclusion of a "pretty boy" ...first its With Love, then Stranger and now Reach Out...
nothing wrong with it but it is just starting to get a little repetitive now

I don't think shes grown up to be a skank, I just don't see that. I think shes just matured and coming more comfortable with her sexiness etc, and theres nothing wrong with that at all. As I said its not like shes stripping, going out and partying(aka its all across the tabloids like Paris, Britney etc). I just don't see it.

Don't care for this new image, but I'm not surprised she's going down this route. (The song isn't too great either in my opinion.)

Agreed Becky.

yes she is all grown up and matured and all sexy.. just like the way Delta has imaged herself...but i think what becky meant was... she has changed not for the better... where as Delta you can see shes still the same Delta even in her clips!! whereas Hilary's vid clip is more s.exual and all...

i believe that she really wants to move out of the younger audience spotlight and move into the adult scene... (whatever that means.. sometimes i dont make any sense haha)

i personally dont have anything against Hilary in that new film clip.. it is rather different to her other clips that was targeted to younger audiences ...

but i must admit "With love" and "stranger" are my two favourite songs! i love the beat to it!

i still follow Hilarys career no matter what path she takes! ive always been a fan of hers!

xx

i think it's a stupid reason/excuse to release a 'best of' that's all

it's not an excuse... She really wanted to break the contract with the label. But the label didnt allow. so she had to do this.

fair enough

can't say thats a good song or clip..

Maybe thats just some of you, but for me I can definatley still see the same Hilary. and how has she changed not for the better? I just don't see that.

I agree, I think she definatley wants to get out of the younger audience hence the more sexual film clip.

But she made statements that girls who dressed or acted suggestive were "immature" and now she does the same. "Growing up" does not mean you have to dress provocatively or act how she does in this video.

considering the audience at the "Dignity" tour being probably 80% age 1-15, she's going to lose a lot of fans then if she keeps going in this direction..

I really don't like this film clip. She's trying to look sexy but it's just not happening. The whole finger in the mouth, rubbing on the guy look is wierd.

She probably will lose more fans from it, but meh I don't care - her life. Maybe its just me but i'm just over the whole squeaky clean image. I mean I don't like artists that strip etc. I HATE THE PCD, I can't stand them.
and so what if shes a bit more sexual in the clip? is she somehow not allowed to show this side of herself? Just because of her image,and I get that her last album "dignity" she may seem like shes contradicting herself. But i for one don't see that. Its just another side of her we haven't seen. She doesn't go out in public with barely anything on, she doesn't sleep around, etc.

I also know that "growing up" doesn't mean that, but I think shes just more comfortable with who she is, so shes allowing herself for the rest of the world and her fans to see this new side of her. Nothing wrong with that.

I'm all for Hilary Duff being sexy but this clip doesn't depict a sexy Hilary, it's more to the slutty, trashier side of sexy. I agree that Hilary probably feels more comfortable how she is now though - each to their own i guess.

Yeah, each to their own . I guess we all find different things sexy.. what I find sexy you may not and vice versa.

Her full "Best Of" album has leaked in HQ CDRIP Quality.

I believe all the songs have been re-mastered. I love "Holiday" <3

I heard the video was banned in the US. I haven't seen it (don't really want to), but I don't know if they ban videos very often?

And I agree that 'growing up' isn't an excuse to be skanky. I know plenty of people who grew up without getting naked in public or whatever. Becoming skanky isn't grown up. It's grown DOWN!

banned it? wow.
Must have been pretty bad

Yes the video was banned from American Television due to a stupid "tumb sucking" part.

The video however was edited, and the label released the clean version of it.

listening to holiday now

That part wasn't even bad, but oh well cencorship happens.

I know plenty of people that also grew up and didn't become skanky, and omg shes not skanky. Just from this video - its a new direction and so what? she can do what she likes. She wants to get away from all her younger fans, and I can't blame her. But she is NOT skanky, the video to some of you may come across as that, but ugh shes not skanky.

I like holiday

we should make this the official hilary duff topic

Anyways One Day Sales report has been announced by Billboard. Hilary Duff's "Best Of" album is nowhere near Top 10. I'm afraid she wont even hit Top 20.

Things are looking bad for ms. Duff. Oh well, Hollywood records didnt promote the album at all, therefore it was expected to flop.