Former Savage Garden frontman Darren Hayes is disappointed with how his London audition contestant Sophie Paterson is going in Australian Idol.
Paterson, has been in the bottom three for the past two weeks, and according to betting websites is the favourite to be booted next after teenager Brooke Addamo was voted off.
Hayes said he felt "quite protective" of Paterson, the 23-year-old Victorian born singer, who was chosen by himself and Tina Arena in the UK audition.
But believed she had become too caught up with being "slick".
"I feel like maybe the process has overwhelmed her a bit," he said.
"I can understand there's a pressure to conform - you're surrounded by a lovely wardrobe and stylists ... you've got all these resources at your hands, you can be very slick, but I don't think that's what she is."
"When friends at home said she was in the bottom three I was a bit offended, I took it personally."
Paterson was working in a bar when a producer came in to hand out flyers for the first-time London audition.
"The person that we saw was sort of frail, introverted, tiny little Joni Mitchell, who came in with her acoustic guitar and she was very unassuming," Hayes said.
"If she gets voted off for the girl that she was in the pub in London I just think she'll feel better about herself."
Hayes, now based in the UK, is mentoring contestants this week, and will be a guest judge on Sunday.
He said he didn't believe he could survive such a competition, and wanted to help the singers be "performers" for Aussie Hits week.
"I don't think these shows should just be a machine that takes someone who's a diamond in the rough and spits them out all shiny," he said.
"I want people to have their angles and their flaws and their scars."
Hayes said he was impressed with Roshani Priddis and Wes Carr, and had glowing praise for Chrislyn Hamilton's latest performance of True Colours.
"The way she looked at the cameras and the things that she said, maybe it's because I'm a gay man, but I related to her feelings of unworthiness," Hayes said.
"And I think that thing when you really expose yourself as a performer, to me that's what makes a star."
Meanwhile, a disappointed Addamo also tipped Carr or Priddis to win.
The Melbourne school girl vowed to continue her music career.
"I had a pretty good run, but it's more than the judges comments, it's the public voting and the popularity and things like that," Addamo said.
"It must have been just my time to go."
http://news.ninemsn.com.au/article.aspx?id=636061