there have been, like 4 seasons on Aussie idol, don't you think its a bit old now?

Yep so is reality tv now where are some decent shows on tv where you could sit down after dinner and watch

No. I love it.

Last night's ep was heaps gooood.

do you guys live in another state than W.A, cause i don't think it was on here last night

Yes, Im over it dramatically..

Yes. Especially when the runner ups are more successful than the actual winners!

LOL
That has happend every time!!!!!!!!!!
Though Kaye Derouge has been more succesfull than Paulini

^^^Paulini wasn't Kate's runner up ... Emily Williams was haha .. but yeah still Kate was more successful ...

But yeah, personally I'm really over it! Really enjoyed the first one, second wasn't too bad, but hardly watched the third! I'll prob watch Top 12 though ... (if Where Are They Now isn't on! )

It's only the auditions which are interesting..

I love Aus Idol. At least they get something out of it, rather then Big Brother and some of the other reality tv shows where they win and you never hear of them again, except for some of them such as Blair Mcdonough and Dan O'Conner.

It is rather old now, Im only watching this year for my friend!

no, still love it.

not really......

big brother.........now THAT is getting old!!

It is getting a little old but I still like it. Pity that the winner and runner up, let alone the other finalists don't really make it in the pop industry, for long at least.

no, Idol is really good. It gives people who have talent a chance to get out there and share their music with the world

I love music, I love Idol

I just hope they allow a wider range of music this year, I want to hear some C&W

Kind Regards,

deltaluva2

I think that they should have some respect for the auditionees though.

Only person who has truly done something with Idol is Kelly; "what about Shannon Noll you may say" - he's had a bit of success in Australia, he hasn't gone international. A couple of measley hits in Australia means nothing and most of the time record companies won't even keep you because you can't generate sufficent profits from one 19million people population country.

And Idol is the chicken route - I don't even respect Kelly for taking that route; if singing means that much to you and you're SO talented - do it the hard way like everybody else.

mehh i watch it to fill in timeeeee

I like the fact Idol is going to new places like Alice Springs and other country towns so we can unearth new talent. if were to have Idol # 5 i think Idol should go to other new country towns like Traralgon, Sale, Ballarat of Victoria and likewise towns in other states.

yes its so boring!

i still like it, so far. neighbours is over 20 years old and it's still running.

not as old as BB

Y.E.S


after 3 seasons we haven't achieved any MAJOR successes. yes, shannon noll is pretty good and anthony could do opera with those pipes, and axel has a great career on video, but ultimately, what does the winner achieve? a spot on "it takes two," appearances at local functions and a cancelled contract? not very starlicious.

so yes, australian idol is a failed concept which has hindered the careers of its winner rather than started them. you've got better chance if you actually lose.

Kate is going ok at the moment with her gig with Young Divas aka Ricki, Paulini and Emily-runner up, when is her debut single and album out?

Hmm, i like Idol it's gives singers the chance to have a career in singing and other fields of work. And, you have to admit most of the singers from Idol who have got record contracts are talented (except Casey and Lee)

Yes! its annoying! and its only been on twice this year

I Love the auditions!!
so funny to watch
and i want it to be on next year so that Ryan can audition and get through and win